November 12, 2026

Quick answer
A backlink strategy is a written plan for earning links. It says which pages need links, how many they need, which tactics will earn them, and how you will measure the result.
Most link building fails because it starts with outreach. A strategy starts with research, and outreach is only step five.
This post gives you the seven step plan, a worked 90-day example with numbers, an anchor text plan you can copy, and a monthly review routine.
What is a backlink strategy?
A backlink strategy is a plan that connects links to rankings. It starts from the pages you want to rank, works out how many links those pages need, then picks the tactics that can earn them.
A tactic is one way to earn a link. Guest posting is a tactic. Broken link building and the skyscraper technique are tactics too.
A strategy is the plan that chooses between them. It says which tactics fit your site, your budget, and your pages, and in what order to run them. Our first post explains what backlinks are, and our guide on how to get backlinks covers the tactics themselves.
Without a strategy, outreach becomes random. You email whoever replies, you accept whatever links come back, and your link profile grows in every direction at once.
Why most link building fails without one
Most failed link building has the same shape. A site owner sends a hundred emails and earns a few links to random pages.
Three months later, rankings have not moved. The links were real, but they pointed at pages that did not need them.
A strategy prevents that in three ways. First, it forces you to pick pages before you pick prospects, because a link to a page that targets no keyword is a link with no job. Second, it forces you to count the gap.
Third, it forces you to measure. A tactic that earns no links after 100 emails is a tactic to drop, not repeat. The plan below takes about a week to build, and it saves months of wasted outreach.
Step 1: Set a goal for each page
Start with ten pages, no more. List the keyword each page targets, and the position it holds today.
Then look at the pages that rank in the top five for each keyword. Note how many referring domains they have, not how many backlinks. Our post on referring domains vs backlinks explains the difference in full, with a worked example.
The gap between your page and the top five is your target. If the top five average 60 referring domains and your page has 12, your page needs about 48 more.
Write the target next to each page. A page with no target gets no links this quarter, however easy the links look.
Rank your ten pages by how close each one is to page one, and how much the page is worth to your business. A page on position 12 for a buying keyword beats a page on position 40 for a traffic keyword.
Step 2: Audit your profile before you build on it

Open the Links report in Google Search Console. It shows your top linked pages, the sites linking to you, and your most common anchor text. For a deeper view, use a backlink tool such as Ahrefs, Semrush, or Moz Link Explorer, which list referring domains and flag links you gained or lost.
When you audit, look for four things.
Pages that already attract links. Some pages earn links without any effort. Those are your best candidates for an update and more promotion.
Anchor text that repeats too much. If most of your links use the exact same keyword phrase, your profile looks forced. Note the share of exact match anchors now, so you can fix it in step 6.
Links that point at dead pages. A backlink to a 404 page passes nothing. Redirect those pages, or ask the site owner to point the link at a live page.
Links you would rather not have. Spam links from unrelated sites are usually ignored by Google, so leave most of them alone. Only consider a disavow when there is a clear pattern of manipulation.
Our guide on how to disavow backlinks covers when to act and when to leave links alone.
Write down three starting numbers: total referring domains, links lost in the last 90 days, and the share of exact match anchors.
Step 3: Find the gap in your competitors
Pick three to five competitors whose pages sit above yours, not the biggest sites in your niche.
Export their referring domains and look for sites that link to two or more of them but not to you. This is often called a link gap or link intersect analysis.
Sites on that list are warmer prospects than sites chosen at random, because they already link to pages like yours.
Sort the list by relevance first and authority second. A relevant site with a modest audience beats a famous site with no connection to your topic. Our guide on how to check competitor backlinks walks through the full process.
Then remove anything that looks like a directory, a link farm, or a site with no recent posts. Most raw lists shrink by half or more at this step, and that is normal.
Step 4: Pick the pages worth linking to
Not every page deserves links. No editor links to a sales page with no useful content.
The pages that earn links have one of four shapes.
A guide that answers a whole topic. A complete guide saves a writer from explaining the topic themselves, so one link replaces a long paragraph.
Original data or research. A number no other site has is easy to cite. A small survey of your own customers can produce one.
A free tool or template. A calculator, a checklist, or a template solves a problem in seconds, and writers link to tools their readers can use.
A real case with real results. A case study proves a claim with evidence, not opinion, and writers link to proof.
Check your ten pages from step 1 against this list. The pages that match one of the four shapes are your linkable pages.
For the rest, improve the page until it matches a shape, or build one new linkable page for the quarter. One strong linkable page beats ten thin pages that nobody wants to link to.
Step 5: Choose two or three tactics, not twelve
Every guide lists a dozen tactics. Running all of them at once is how teams burn out and earn nothing.
Pick two or three that match your skills and budget, and set a modest target, such as 20 personalised outreach emails per week.
Here are the tactics most teams can run without paying for links or breaking search guidelines.
Guest posting. You write a useful article for another site in your topic, with a link back to your page where it fits naturally.
Link insertions. You ask a site to add your link to a page they already published, where your page fills a gap.
Broken link building. You find dead links on relevant pages and offer your page as the working replacement.
Resource page outreach. You suggest your page for a list of useful links a site keeps for its readers.
Digital PR and expert quotes. You answer journalist requests with a short expert quote. It suits founders and recognised experts, and it can earn links from news sites.
Skyscraper. You build a clearly better version of a page that already earns links, then email the sites that link to the old page. Our post on the skyscraper technique covers the three steps, the email templates, and the results to expect.
Unlinked mention reclamation. You find sites that name your brand without linking, then ask them to add a link. It is the easiest link of all, because the writer already knows who you are.
Two tactics are enough to start. Add a third only when the first two are running smoothly, and drop any tactic that earns nothing after a fair test. If your team has no time for pitching, our blogger outreach service handles it, and agencies that resell link building can use our white-label link building service.
Read our guide on good backlinks for the ten signals that make a link worth winning, and apply them to every prospect on your list.
Step 6: Plan your anchor text before you earn a link
Anchor text is the clickable words in a link. It tells Google what the linked page is about, and a natural profile uses many kinds of anchor text.
Branded anchors use your business name, URL anchors use the web address itself, and generic anchors use words like “this guide” or “click here”. Partial match anchors include part of your keyword, and exact match anchors use the full keyword phrase.
A common practitioner guideline puts branded, URL, and generic anchors at 60 to 70 percent of a profile, partial match at 10 to 20 percent, and exact match at 10 to 20 percent.
That mix is a guideline, not a Google rule. Google has never published an ideal anchor mix, and no tool can tell you the exact mix for your niche.
What matters is the direction. A profile where most anchors are exact match looks built, not earned.
You cannot control how other sites write their anchors, and you should never ask for exact match text in every email. What you can control is which pages you promote.
Set your target mix now, before the first email. Then check the real mix every month, and steer the next month toward the kind you lack.
Worked example: fixing an over-optimised profile
Say your site has 40 links today, and the audit from step 2 shows this mix.
| Anchor type | Links today | Share today |
|---|---|---|
| Exact match | 24 | 60 percent |
| Partial match | 6 | 15 percent |
| Branded | 6 | 15 percent |
| URL and generic | 4 | 10 percent |
That profile is upside down. Exact match anchors lead, and branded anchors trail, which is the pattern Google associates with built links.
Your next 20 links should pull the mix back toward the guideline. Aim for this split on the new links.
| Anchor type | New links | Target share of new links |
|---|---|---|
| Branded | 8 | 40 percent |
| URL and generic | 6 | 30 percent |
| Partial match | 4 | 20 percent |
| Exact match | 2 | 10 percent |
After those 20 links, the profile has 60 links in total, exact match falls to about 43 percent, and branded rises to about 23 percent.
One quarter will not fix a year of exact match links, but the direction is right, and two more quarters at the same pace bring the profile close to the guideline.
Step 7: Set the pace, the budget, and the review date
Set three numbers now: how many new referring domains per month, how many outreach emails per week, and what each link may cost.
Link velocity is the pace at which new referring domains appear. A steady pace looks natural. A sudden spike of hundreds of links from unknown sites does not.
Use these guardrails as rules of thumb, not as Google rules, because Google publishes no safe speed.
| Site stage | New referring domains per month |
|---|---|
| New site, under 20 referring domains | 5 to 10 |
| Growing site, 20 to 100 referring domains | 10 to 25 |
| Established site, over 100 referring domains | 25 to 50, or match your competitors |
A new site that gains 100 referring domains in a month looks unnatural, unless a piece of content genuinely goes viral. An established site can gain more, because its baseline is higher.
Outreach volume follows from the target. Hunter studied 31 million emails sent in 2025 and found an average cold email sequence reply rate of 4.5 percent.
Backlinko and Pitchbox studied 12 million outreach emails and found only 8.5 percent receive any reply at all. Plan on a link rate of 2 to 8 percent of emails sent, so to earn 10 links in a quarter, expect to send roughly 150 to 300 good emails.
Budget follows from the volume. Count hours, not just fees. Prospecting, writing, and outreach take real time.
If you outsource, ask for the price per link earned, not per email sent. Our link building pricing page explains what sits inside a package and what never does.
Worked example: a 90-day strategy with numbers

The numbers below are illustrative. They show how one small business could run a full quarter, step by step.
Say you run a small online store that sells handmade soap. Your site has 18 referring domains. Your main page targets “handmade soap gift sets” and sits on position 14.
Week 1: set goals and audit. You list ten pages and check the top five for each keyword. The pages above you for “handmade soap gift sets” average 60 referring domains. Your page has 9.
The gap is 51 referring domains. You will not close it in one quarter, so you set a 90-day target of 12 new referring domains for that page, and 6 for your gift guide. The audit shows 18 referring domains, 3 links lost in 90 days, and 40 percent exact match anchors.
Weeks 1 to 2: find the gap. You pick four competitors and export their referring domains. Sites linking to two or more of them give you a list of 180 domains.
You remove directories, dead sites, and sites with no recent posts. The list shrinks to 74 real prospects, sorted by relevance first.
Weeks 2 to 3: build the asset. Your gift guide is thin, so you rebuild it: six gift sets with photos, prices, and a short note on who each set suits, plus a one page printable gift guide as a download.
That page is now your linkable asset. The product page itself is not, because no editor links to a shop page without a reason.
Weeks 3 to 12: outreach. You pick two tactics: guest posting on craft and gift blogs, and resource page outreach to gift guides and handmade directories. You send 20 personalised emails a week, 240 in the quarter.
At a 4.5 percent reply rate, that is about 11 replies. At a 5 percent link rate on emails sent, that is 12 links, which matches your target.
Months 2 to 3: the long tail. The rebuilt guide starts ranking, and three more sites link to it without any email, because they found it in search.
You end the quarter with 15 new referring domains against a target of 18, and the gift guide moves from position 14 to position 8.
Which strategy fits your site?
Use this chooser to pick your first tactics and your monthly target.
| Your site today | First three tactics | Monthly target |
|---|---|---|
| New site, under 20 referring domains | Unlinked mentions, resource pages, guest posts on small blogs | 5 to 10 new referring domains |
| Growing site, 20 to 100 referring domains | Guest posts, broken link building, skyscraper on one strong page | 10 to 25 new referring domains |
| Established site, over 100 referring domains | Digital PR, original data, skyscraper, guest posts on bigger sites | 25 to 50 new referring domains |
| Local business | Citations, local resource pages, local press and community sites | 5 to 15 new referring domains |
| E-commerce store | Gift guides and roundups, resource pages, product reviews by bloggers | 10 to 20 new referring domains |
A new site should not start with digital PR. A new site has no track record for journalists to cite, and the effort earns nothing.
An established site should not spend a quarter on directory submissions. The links are weak, and the site needs authority links, not volume.
If you are new, start with resource page outreach and unlinked mentions, because they take the least effort. Add guest posting once you have a steady routine.
How to measure it: the monthly review

Set aside one hour on the same day each month, and check five numbers.
New referring domains. How many new sites linked to you this month, and to which pages. Compare with your target from step 7.
Links lost. How many referring domains disappeared. A few lost links a month is normal.
Referral traffic. Did the linking pages send any visits. A link that moves a page up for a useful keyword is worth more than one that changes nothing.
Rankings for your ten pages. Did the pages you targeted move. Ranking changes take months, so judge a quarter, not a week.
Anchor text mix. Did the mix move toward your target from step 6. Steer next month toward the kind you lack.
Then apply three decision rules to each tactic you ran.
| Result after a fair test | Decision |
|---|---|
| Link rate of 3 percent or more on emails sent | Keep it, and give it more time next month |
| Reply rate under 2 percent after 60 emails | Fix the email or the page, then test again |
| Zero links after 100 emails | Stop it, and swap in a new tactic |
A fair test means at least a month and at least 60 to 100 emails. Judging a tactic after ten emails tells you nothing.
Keep a simple record with four columns: tactic, prospects contacted, replies, and links earned. After a month, work out the reply rate and the link rate for each tactic.
Drop the tactics that earn only weak links, and give every new tactic at least a month before you judge it.
Good vs bad backlink strategy
| Good strategy | Bad strategy |
|---|---|
| Starts from pages and keywords | Starts from a list of sites to email |
| Counts the gap before outreach | Guesses how many links are needed |
| Picks two or three tactics | Tries twelve tactics at once |
| Plans anchor text in advance | Accepts whatever anchor text arrives |
| Sets a steady monthly pace | Buys 200 links in one week |
| Measures links earned, not emails sent | Counts opens and calls it a win |
| Reviews monthly and drops dead tactics | Repeats the same failing tactic |
| Builds one linkable page per quarter | Points outreach at thin sales pages |
Read the right column before you start. Most failed plans fail on two or three of those rows.
Five mistakes that kill a backlink strategy
Skipping the audit is the first mistake. Building on a profile you never checked is like building on ground you never surveyed.
Chasing volume over relevance is the second mistake. A hundred links from unrelated sites will not beat ten links from sites your customers actually read.
Ignoring anchor text is the third mistake. A profile where every link uses the same keyword phrase looks built, and it invites a closer look from Google.
Setting no target is the fourth mistake. Without a monthly target for new referring domains, you cannot tell whether the plan is working or drifting.
Quitting after one month is the last mistake. Links take weeks to appear and months to move rankings, so a strategy judged after 30 days is a strategy never tested.
FAQs
What is a backlink strategy?
It is a written plan for earning links. It says which pages need links, how many they need, which tactics will earn them, and how you will measure the result. A tactic is one way to earn a link, and a strategy is the plan that chooses between tactics, and in what order to run them.
How many backlinks do I need?
There is no fixed number. Study the top five pages for your keyword, count their referring domains, and aim to close the gap one steady quarter at a time. A small site in a quiet niche may need 20 strong referring domains, while a page in a competitive niche may need hundreds.
How long does a backlink strategy take to work?
Some tactics, such as reclaiming unlinked mentions, can earn links within weeks. Content led tactics, such as guides, data, and tools, often take months to earn their first links. Ranking changes take longer still, so expect months, not days, before positions move.
What is a good anchor text mix?
A common practitioner guideline is 60 to 70 percent branded, URL, and generic anchors, 10 to 20 percent partial match, and 10 to 20 percent exact match.
That mix is a guideline, not a Google rule. What matters is the direction: branded and generic anchors should lead, and exact match anchors should stay a small share.
Should I buy backlinks as part of my strategy?
No, not as a way to pass ranking value. Google treats paid links that pass ranking value as link spam under its spam policies.
If you pay for a placement, mark the link with rel=”sponsored”, as Google explains in its guide to qualifying outbound links. Treat it as advertising, not as earned editorial, and keep it out of your link targets.
Can a new website use this plan?
Yes, but start small. Pick the new site row in the chooser table above, target 5 to 10 new referring domains a month, and aim at longer tail keywords first. A new site will not beat a page with 500 referring domains from a famous publisher, so win on modest targets first, then aim higher.
Closing
Pick the pages, count the gap, build something worth linking to, choose two or three tactics, and measure every month.
Most people fail on the first step, emailing before they plan, or on the last, never checking whether the work earned anything.
Do the planning properly, and the outreach becomes the easy part. Every email has a reason, every link has a job, and every month tells you what to do next.
If you want the plan built for you, whether for your own site or for your clients, contact us and tell us about your site. We will tell you honestly which route fits.
Looking for Quality Backlinks?
Let Outreach Legends help you find relevant websites and manage your link-building outreach from start to finish.